bad reviews (6 Viewers)

[rettucs]

this is a bit cuntish of the Irish Times. Its right there at the top of their front page.

 

[Cornu Ammonis]

this is a bit cuntish of the Irish Times. Its right there at the top of their front page.

View attachment 20109

Well, is it true?

 

[rettucs]

Well, is it true?

maybe but if they're claiming its the worst chicken burger they've ever had, they should list every chicken burger they've ever had, so we know what they're comparing with.

 

[nuke terrorist]

Who cares?
Food critics are the lowest form of journalist.

 

[magicbastarder]

maybe but if they're claiming its the worst chicken burger they've ever had, they should list every chicken burger they've ever had, so we know what they're comparing with.

if they say a dish is the best they've ever had, they should likewise list every meal they've ever eaten too.

 

[rettucs]

if they say a dish is the best they've ever had, they should likewise list every meal they've ever eaten too.

agreed

 

[rettucs]

Who cares?
Food critics are the lowest form of journalist.

the people who work there.

I have no skin in the game but I expect this review will trash their business.

It seemed an overly harsh way of saying they didn't like the food they got.

 

[magicbastarder]

is it not a truism that a bad review boosts traffic to a restaurant?

 

[rettucs]

is it not a truism that a bad review boosts traffic to a restaurant?

people flocking to try the shit food. makes sense

 

[nuke terrorist]

the people who work there.

I have no skin in the game but I expect this review will trash their business.

It seemed an overly harsh way of saying they didn't like the food they got.

Food critics should get proper jobs.
Yes, this was written in a nasty way.

 

[seanc]

Jay Rayner and the late Paulo Tulio are excellent writers.

 

[nuke terrorist]

Paulo Tuilio is dead, he wasted his talent writing about food.
Milo Aukerman is good food writer.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Accept third party cookies

 

[magicbastarder]

Food critics should get proper jobs.
Yes, this was written in a nasty way.

what made you dislike food critics so much?

 

[nuke terrorist]

what made you dislike food critics so much?

Firstly the reference to Tuilio was after seanc referred to him in the present tense before the post was edited.

Someone getting paid to eat a meal and then write about it has zero value IMO.
The person could be a fine writer but the are just expressing an opinion on a meal they ate.

When I was about 15/16 a nice English teacher read out an Irish Times article where Helen Lucy Burke reviewed a meal at Dublin Zoo restaurant as a class exercise.
It was a rubbish article and the meal cost £35 circa 1991.

 

[egg_]

Who cares?
Food critics are the lowest form of journalist.

I care! I like to eat nice food, and I hate eating shit food. Restaurant reviews are useful to me

 

[egg_]

this is a bit cuntish of the Irish Times. Its right there at the top of their front page.

If you're selling vile food then you are the asshole

(I agree that it's pretty harsh though)

 

[seanc]

Firstly the reference to Tuilio was after seanc referred to him in the present tense before the post was edited.

Someone getting paid to eat a meal and then write about it has zero value IMO.
The person could be a fine writer but the are just expressing an opinion on a meal they ate.

When I was about 15/16 a nice English teacher read out an Irish Times article where Helen Lucy Burke reviewed a meal at Dublin Zoo restaurant as a class exercise.
It was a rubbish article and the meal cost £35 circa 1991.

Are you still 15/16"? Not to be too imperious about it.

 

[nuke terrorist]

Does anyone review toilets?

Are you still 15/16"? Not to be too imperious about it.

I am 49 if you do the maths. My opinions haven't changed a massive amount in the last few decades.
EDIT:
Paying someone to eat dead animals and write about how they didn't taste nice is fairly pathetic.

 

[magicbastarder]

Same for book/movie/music reviewers?

 

[seanc]

Does anyone review toilets?

I am 49 if you do the maths. My opinions haven't changed a massive amount in the last few decades.
EDIT:
Paying someone to eat dead animals and write about how they didn't taste nice is fairly pathetic.

I can do the maths. That wasn't the wordplay I was aiming at.

You seem far too clever to be holding on to these things.

Anyway, the last ten posts here get a 2 out of ten for me. Or maybe nine out of ten, depends what mood I'm in.