Thumped album club (1 Viewer)

[pete]

Not one of my albums was picked as far as I can tell

There were a few hundred nominations. It's a miracle any got more than one vote.

 

[GO]

How about next year we pick only albums from 2017, the latest new releases? We'll all be totally tuned in by this time next year

This is a great idea.

Would force me to listen to the absolute dross thats being made currently

 

[travispickle]

I'm doubting my own commitment to Thumped Album Club

 

[Cornu Ammonis]

There were a few hundred nominations. It's a miracle any got more than one vote.

I still think you should randomly pick some of the one vote wonders.

 

[chris d]

Are we having a clean slate and new vote for 2017?

Would limiting the size of the list be a good idea?

 

[pete]

Are we having a clean slate and new vote for 2017?

Would limiting the size of the list be a good idea?

Yes and yes

 

[rettucs]

I'm just gonna vote for the same stuff again, though I'll limit it to just those from my list that have come up already.

 

[Cornu Ammonis]

I might just put the same Fushitsusha album down ten times.

 

[hydromancer]

If there is that many submissions it's probably only feasible that each person gets at least one and maybe two picked out. But possibly it is fairer then to do it in a systematic way otherwise some voters will have multiple albums chosen with others none at all. Five choices could be enough for submission with preference given to number one or just randomly picked?

 

[rettucs]

If there is that many submissions it's probably only feasible that each person gets at least one and maybe two picked out. But possibly it is fairer then to do it in a systematic way otherwise some voters will have multiple albums chosen with others none at all. Five choices could be enough for submission with preference given to number one or just randomly picked?

if you were gonna do it that way then maybe there's no need for a list of albums. Just have a list of people who want to take part, @pete contacts one on the sly every week, and the choose the album for that week.

It's a way of ensuring everyone's picks feature, eventually.

 

[hydromancer]

That would also work I suppose it needs to be lock tight though otherwise conspiracy theories will emerge. Maybe even throw up the three hundred to have a look if its being restarted ?

(Also hopefully no more Morrisey)

 

[chris d]

What about just voting 2 albums each.

 

[HMD]

At this stage we're nearly through my list, may as well just do the last couple.

 

[GO]

I fucking knew it!

FIX!

 

[rettucs]

What's happening with this?

Carry on as before? Or submit new suggestions?

 

[pete]

Back in action tonight. I'm picking.

Need to think about a 2017 approach though.

 

[Cornu Ammonis]

Back in action tonight. I'm picking.

Need to think about a 2017 approach though.

All live albums.

 

[pete]

All live albums.

i actually considered going with Life, because i think it's amazing...

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Accept third party cookies

 

[Cornu Ammonis]

Live and Dangerous would have been better as I have it twice.

 

[Denny Oubidoux]

How about we do a song a week instead of an album?